Dangers Of Plastics

About three months ago, as part of Lia’s ever-increasing demand for nutritional edible goods, we added Yo Baby to Lia’s diet for breakfast. 

yobaby

It seemed sensible at the time, as Yo Baby is an organic yogurt that, according to its manufacturers, helps promote brain development with its whole milk, helps body growth with calcium and protein, is all natural and certified organic, helps digestion with its active cultures, and contains reduced sugar, which is about as much as a jar of baby food fruit. Lia enjoyed this little cold, sweet treat, and for three months, she had a container’s worth of yogurt every morning. Little did we know that months later, we would discover that this very yogurt, touted to be healthy, would come in a toxic container known to be carcinogenic.

In retrospect, we should have paid more attention when we read the July 2008 issue of the ShopSmart magazine, where an article titled “How Safe Is That Plastic Container” revealed a few recycle numbers (resin identification code) to avoid, including that which contains Yo Baby. After doing a little research, I’ve deciphered the incomprehensible recycle digits and valuable information on each:

Number Abbr Description
recycle11
PET/PETE Polyethylene terephthalate. Used in water bottles, juice, and sports drinks. PET breaks down over time and the toxin DEHA leaches into beverages when bottles are reused. DEHA can cause liver and reproductive problems and can cause cancer. Avoid recycling reusing because they’re porous and can absorb flavors and bacteria that can’t be cleaned.
recycle21 HDPE Commonly used for milk jugs, liquid detergent bottles, shampoo bottles.
recycle31 PVC Polyvinyl chloride. Commonly used for meat wrap, cooking oil bottles, and plumbing pipes.  Can cause cancer, birth defects, damage to kidneys, lungs, and reproductive organs.
recycle41 LDPE Low density polyethylene. Commonly used in cling wrap, grocery bags, and sandwich bags.
recycle51 PP Polypropylen. Commonly used in cloudy plastic water bottles, yogurt cups/tubs.
recycle61 PS Polystyrene. Commonly used for disposable coffee cups, clam-shell take-out containers. Polystyrene-foam cups and clear plastic take-out containers can leach styrene, a possible human carcinogen, into food.
recycle71 PC Polycarbonate. Commonly used for some food storage, sports bottles, and baby bottles. Contains Bisphenol A (BPA), which can cause breast and prostate cancer, diabetes, birth defects, and child hyperactivity. Can leach into food if exposed to heat or are scratched, cracked, or worm from repeated use and dishwashing.
recycle71 PLA PLA is made from corn, potato, or sugar cane, and is safe and can be composted. Unfortunately this is also classified as “#7: Other”, along with BPA and newer non-BPA plastics.

Now you may wonder if some of these plastics are so harmful, why are they still in use? The reason is that the FDA decided that the levels of harmful chemicals leaching into food is within safety limits. Some new studies, however, seem to show that there are potential risks from even low levels of exposure, including a new draft report from the National Institutes of Health.

With that, we now move on to some practical steps for protecting you and your love ones from the toxic plastics:

  • Use #2 HDPE, #4 LDPE, and #5 PP
  • Use #1 PET, but don’t recycle the water/soda bottles
  • Use PLA
  • Avoid #3 PVC, #6 PS, and #7 PC.
  • Don’t store fatty food with plastic containers or plastic wraps.
  • Microwave-safe only means it won’t melt, crack, or fall apart, but toxic chemical can still leach into food. Use glass or ceramic.

And if you’re really paranoid concerned, you can even:

  • When buying meat packaged with cling wrap, slice off a thin portion that came into contact with the wrap and store in glass or ceramic container or use non-PVC wrap.

Research has a tendency to keep reversing itself, and someone will probably find some toxicity in one of those recycle numbers that we trust to be safe. The only thing we can do is do our best based on what we know today.

Reader Comments

  1. why would you not recycle water/soda bottles? plastics can be reformed into non-food items. did your magazine make that recommendation? and what kind of plastic is the yobaby container? we stopped feeding toby the baby yogurt when he got older and economized by feeding him the same stuff we eat.

  2. I guess I didn’t provide enough info on the recycling part. It’s because it’s porous and bacteria can get in that cannot be cleaned. I’ve updated my post to reflect this. This was from a difference source, not the magazine. Yo-Baby is #6.

  3. i wrote about these harmful plastics in our blog before sweetpea was born as well but didn’t notice yobaby container number until olivia mentioned it. http://urciafamily.blogspot.com/2008/05/chemicals-everywhere.html ugh! the big size stonyfield farms whole milk yogurt is the same thing in a safer container… only you may not get the variety of flavors that they have for yobaby… I think they only come in plain or french vanilla so you’d have to mix in your own fruit.

Leave a Reply